Selling Sayreville,
one neighbor at a time.
Donna has worked the Sayreville and Parlin market for more than 35 years, closing hundreds of millions of dollars in residential and commercial sales. Most of her business comes from referrals and past clients, and she answers her own phone.
The Reserve at
Crossways Creek
44 luxury townhomes on Bonus Court in Sayreville: now selling, construction underway. From $579,000, by appointment only.
See the community →
Thirty-five years,
one market, one phone number.
Donna has worked the Sayreville and Parlin market for more than 35 years, closing hundreds of millions of dollars in residential and commercial sales. Most of her business comes from referrals and past clients, and she answers her own phone.
“My Service Makes the Difference”
Read her full storyAwards she can date, verify, and prove
What neighbors say
The best choice we made in our home buying journey was choosing Donna as our realtor. She is knowledgeable and always available to answer any questions and show houses. I highly recommend anyone looking for a new home to use Donna T!
Working with Donna was a great experience. She was knowledgeable and always very responsive. Throughout the entire process, she answered all of my questions, and kept me informed every step of the way, making what could have been a stressful experience feel much more manageable.
Donna Tennaro was absolutely amazing to work with throughout the sale of our home. From start to finish, she went above and beyond to make the process as smooth and stress-free as possible. Her knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and constant communication gave us complete confidence every step of the way. We couldn't have asked for a better experience and would highly recommend Donna to anyone buying or selling a home. She genuinely cares about her clients and is simply outstanding. Thank you, Donna, for all of your hard work and dedication. You exceeded our expectations in every way!
i was helping my parents to sell their house and move to an 55 and older community. Donna was the best she would answer my phone calls answer any questions i had ,set us up with Matthew and took care of everything we needed done with little to no hassle at all .i give donna 5 stars and would give her more if it would allow me to.thank you so much Donna.
I was selling my parent home as they recently moved into assisted living. I'm over 4 hours from the property. So, I expected this process would be difficult. On the contrary Donna made this whole process easy and effective. This sale process could not have been managed any better. Donna handled everything seamlessly from initial conversations, market knowledge, pricing strategy, listing / viewing process, offer process and closing. I'm not sure you can find anyone better than Donna.
Donna was an absolute pleasure to work with. Her knowledge and experience are unmatched. She made us feel like her top priority. She answered all of our questions regardless of the hour. As first time home buyers, she made the process so easy to navigate. She also has an amazing team that went above and beyond just like she did throughout the process. I would highly recommend her and her company to help anyone in their buying or selling experience!
Donna is rated 4.9 ★ on Google with 86 reviews. read them all ↗ · Zillow ↗
Her market, block by block
Sayreville · Parlin · Old Bridge · Matawan · East Brunswick
Waterfront Borough on Raritan Bay: Lake Caroline, Port Read, and a housing stock from wartime cottages to new 55-plus communities. Donna's home market.
The crossroads of Sayreville and the Route 9 corridor: ranches, splits and colonials on lots you can still use, minutes from the Garden State Parkway.
Monmouth County's most-sold township, a ten-minute drive west, with steady demand and a wide range, from starter ranches to executive colonials off Route 9.
Historic Main Street on the bayshore, one bridge north, with commuter rail to Penn Station and a walkable downtown that keeps drawing buyers back.
College-adjacent Middlesex with the Route 18 and NJ Turnpike access: condos, townhomes and larger ranches on both sides of US-1.
Bayshore borough minutes over the Sayreville border: Raritan River waterfront, a walkable Main Street, and steady demand for modestly priced ranches and twins.
